Validating care and treatment scenarios for measuring decisional conflict regarding future care preferences among older adults

Article indépendant

SINCLAIR, Craig | YEOH, Ling | KARUSOO-MUSUMECI, Ava | AURET, Kirsten A. | CLAYTON, Josephine M. | HILGEMAN, Michelle | HALCOMB, Elizabeth | SINCLAIR, Ron | MARTINI, Angelita | MELLER, Anne | WALTON, Rebecca | WEI, Li | DAO-TRAN, Tiet-Hanh | KURRLE, Susan | COMANS, Tracy

OBJECTIVE: Decisional conflict is used increasingly as an outcome measure in advance care planning (ACP) studies. When the Decisional Conflict Scale (DCS) is used in anticipatory decision-making contexts, the scale is typically tethered to hypothetical scenarios. This study reports preliminary validation data for hypothetical scenarios relating to life-sustaining treatments and care utilisation to inform their broader use in ACP studies. METHODS: Three hypothetical scenarios were developed by a panel of multidisciplinary researchers, clinicians and community representatives. A convenience sample of 262 older adults were surveyed. Analyses investigated comprehensibility, missing data properties, sample norms, structural, convergent and discriminant validity. RESULTS: Response characteristics suggested that two of the scenarios had adequate comprehensibility and response spread. Missing response rates were unrelated to demographic characteristics. Predicted associations between DCS scores and anxiety (r's = .31–.37, p < .001), and ACP engagement (r's = -.41 to -.37, p < .001) indicated convergent validity. CONCLUSION: A substantial proportion of older adults reported clinically significant levels of decisional conflict when responding to a range of hypothetical scenarios about care or treatment. Two scenarios showed acceptable comprehensibility and response characteristics. A third scenario may be suitable following further refinement. PATIENT OR PUBLIC CONTRIBUTION: The scenarios tested here were designed in collaboration with a community representative and were further piloted with two groups of community members with relevant lived experiences; four people with life-limiting conditions and five current or former care partners.

http://dx.doi.org/10.1111/hex.14010

Voir la revue «Health expectations, 27»

Autres numéros de la revue «Health expectations»

Consulter en ligne

Suggestions

Du même auteur

Validating care and treatment scenarios for m...

Article | SINCLAIR, Craig | Health expectations | n°2 | vol.27

OBJECTIVE: Decisional conflict is used increasingly as an outcome measure in advance care planning (ACP) studies. When the Decisional Conflict Scale (DCS) is used in anticipatory decision-making contexts, the scale is typically te...

Factors associated with advance care planning...

Article indépendant | DAO-TRAN, Tiet-Hanh | Journal of clinical nursing

AIM: To explore the associations between depression, anxiety, decisional conflict and advance care planning engagement and the potential mediating role of decisional conflict in the associations between depression, anxiety and adv...

Could life story work support relational auto...

Article indépendant | KARUSOO-MUSUMECI, Ava | Australasian journal on ageing | n°2 | vol.44

OBJECTIVES: Advance care planning has evolved from a narrow focus on advance directives completion towards a greater emphasis on ongoing conversations and value clarification. This evolution aligns with a relational perspective on...

De la même série

Announcements of death during the covid-19 pa...

Article indépendant | AVAZERI, Axelle | Health expectations | n°2 | vol.28

INTRODUCTION: Health restrictions resulting from COVID-19 made it more difficult for families to mourn. The death announcement is a significant moment for families. The aim of this study was to explore the experiences, perceptions...

Implementation, processes and outcomes of adv...

Article indépendant | ZHOU, Yuxin | Health expectations | n°3 | vol.28

BACKGROUND: Despite advance care planning (ACP) being associated with positive outcomes for residents in long-term care facilities (LTCFs), the causal pathways between ACP and these outcomes are context-specific and less understoo...

Validating care and treatment scenarios for m...

Article indépendant | SINCLAIR, Craig | Health expectations | n°2 | vol.27

OBJECTIVE: Decisional conflict is used increasingly as an outcome measure in advance care planning (ACP) studies. When the Decisional Conflict Scale (DCS) is used in anticipatory decision-making contexts, the scale is typically te...

Advancing the care experience for patients re...

Article indépendant | MCCOY, Madeline | Health expectations | n°2 | vol.27

BACKGROUND: Returning home from the hospital for palliative-focused care is a common transition, but the process can be emotionally distressing and logistically challenging for patients and caregivers. While interventions exist to...

Patients' and caregivers' suggestions for imp...

Article indépendant | JEANNERET, Ruthie | Health expectations | n°3 | vol.27

INTRODUCTION: Assisted dying (AD) has been legalised in a small but growing number of jurisdictions globally, including Canada and Australia. Early research in both countries demonstrates that, in response to access barriers, pati...

Chargement des enrichissements...