Assisted death, dignity, and respect for humanity

Article indépendant

DIGE, Morten

Recent works on the concept of dignity have opened up the otherwise quite deadlocked debate about assisted death (AD). Rather than just reinforcing already fixed positions, it seems to me that these conceptions of dignity make room for a moderate and normatively richer position on the moral permissibility of AD. I do not think that we have seen the full potential of the said conceptions and interpretations. I try in this article to contribute my part. First, I briefly recapitulate some of the paradoxical ways in which dignity is typically invoked in the debate and try to clear up some of the obvious confusions. Then, I go on to explore a particular Kantian line of thought in some recent works on dignity and AD that seems to pave the way for a moderate position with a more principled foundation than the usual compromise positions.

http://dx.doi.org/10.1093/jmp/jhac024

Voir la revue «The journal of medicine and philosophy, 47»

Autres numéros de la revue «The journal of medicine and philosophy»

Consulter en ligne

Suggestions

Du même auteur

Critique of autonomy-based arguments against ...

Article | SOBIRK PETERSEN, Thomas | Bioethics

The aim of this article is to present and critically investigate a type of argument against legalising assisted dying on request (ADR) for patients who are terminally ill and experiencing suffering. This type of argument has sever...

Critique of autonomy-based arguments against ...

Article indépendant | SOBIRK PETERSEN, Thomas | Bioethics

The aim of this article is to present and critically investigate a type of argument against legalising assisted dying on request (ADR) for patients who are terminally ill and experiencing suffering. This type of argument has sever...

Assisted death, dignity, and respect for huma...

Article indépendant | DIGE, Morten | The journal of medicine and philosophy | n°6 | vol.47

Recent works on the concept of dignity have opened up the otherwise quite deadlocked debate about assisted death (AD). Rather than just reinforcing already fixed positions, it seems to me that these conceptions of dignity make roo...

De la même série

Alzheimer's, advance directives, and interpre...

Article indépendant | BARZUN, Charles L. | The journal of medicine and philosophy | n°1 | vol.48

Philosophers have debated whether the advance directives of Alzheimer's patients should be enforced, even if patients seem content in their demented state. The debate raises deep questions about the nature of human autonomy and pe...

A dilemma for respecting autonomy : bridge te...

Article indépendant | KESTIGIAN, Aidan | The journal of medicine and philosophy | n°2 | vol.47

Respect for patient autonomy can apply at two levels: ensuring that patient care reflects their considered values and wishes and honoring patient preferences about how to make momentous decisions. Caregivers who seek to respect pa...

Reasoning about death in biomedical decision-...

Article indépendant | WEISSMAN, Jeremy | The journal of medicine and philosophy | n°3 | vol.47

Depending on our mode of reasoning-moral, prudential, instrumental, empirical, dialectical, and so on-we may come to vastly different conclusions on the nature of death and the appropriate orientation toward matters such as euthan...

Depression and physician-aid-in-dying

Article indépendant | TULLY, Ian | The journal of medicine and philosophy | n°3 | vol.47

In this paper, I address the question of whether it is ever permissible to grant a request for physician-aid-in-dying (PAD) from an individual suffering from treatment-resistant depression. I assume for the sake of argument that P...

Assisted death, dignity, and respect for huma...

Article indépendant | DIGE, Morten | The journal of medicine and philosophy | n°6 | vol.47

Recent works on the concept of dignity have opened up the otherwise quite deadlocked debate about assisted death (AD). Rather than just reinforcing already fixed positions, it seems to me that these conceptions of dignity make roo...

Chargement des enrichissements...