Doctor's criminal liability and medically assisted death - the Portuguese case

Article indépendant

RAPOSO, Vera Lucia

Recently, the Portuguese Parliament discussed four proposals aimed at allowing some forms of medically assisted death. However, all of them were rejected by the majority. Therefore, doctors who in some way accelerate a patient's death risk being convicted of the crime of homicide. Portuguese law provides some legal mechanisms that can exempt a doctor from criminal liability, such as causes excluding the conduct's wrongfulness, and causes excluding the doctor's culpability. Other elements to take into consideration are a proper interpretation of homicide crimes, thereby excluding conducts without the intent to kill; the relevance of patient consent; and the rejection of medical futility. This article explains how a doctor may not be held criminally accountable for medically assisted death, even in restrictive jurisdictions such as the Portuguese one.

http://dx.doi.org/10.1163/15718093-12264430

Voir la revue «European Journal of Health Law, 26»

Autres numéros de la revue «European Journal of Health Law»

Consulter en ligne

Suggestions

Du même auteur

Doctor's criminal liability and medically ass...

Article | RAPOSO, Vera Lucia | European Journal of Health Law | n°3 | vol.26

Recently, the Portuguese Parliament discussed four proposals aimed at allowing some forms of medically assisted death. However, all of them were rejected by the majority. Therefore, doctors who in some way accelerate a patient's d...

De la même série

In dubio pro CPR? the controversial status of...

Article indépendant | LEVY, Melanie | European Journal of Health Law | n°2 | vol.27

'Do not resuscitate' (DNR) imprints on the human body have recently appeared in medical practice. These non-standard DNR orders (e.g., tattoos, stamps, patches) convey the patient's refusal of resuscitation efforts should he be in...

The underappreciated role of advance directiv...

Article indépendant | CHAN, Hui Yun | European Journal of Health Law | n°5 | vol.27

Covid-19 continues to alter our way of living and dying. Much attention has focused on how to resolve pressing issues surrounding resource allocation and competing public health ethics. While these are important discussions, the l...

Doctor's criminal liability and medically ass...

Article indépendant | RAPOSO, Vera Lucia | European Journal of Health Law | n°3 | vol.26

Recently, the Portuguese Parliament discussed four proposals aimed at allowing some forms of medically assisted death. However, all of them were rejected by the majority. Therefore, doctors who in some way accelerate a patient's d...

The Marco Cappato and Fabiano Antoniani (dj F...

Article indépendant | MONTANARI VERGALLO, Gianluca | European Journal of Health Law | n°3 | vol.26

The article looks into the case involving Fabiano Antoniani, who, following a major road accident, was left tetraplegic. Marco Cappato drove him to a Swiss clinic where Mr. Antoniani took his own life by self-administration of let...

Terminal sedation : a legal approach Sédation...

Article indépendant | GEVERS, Sjef | European Journal of Health Law | vol.10

Cet article tente d'apporter des réponses sur la sédation en phase terminale alors que la voie légale donne lieu à de nombreuses interprétations.

Chargement des enrichissements...