Ethics of transitioning from curative care to palliative care : potential conflicts of interest using the example of neurosurgery

Article

SHLOBIN, Nathan A. | SHELDON, Mark | BERNSTEIN, Mark

Objective: Neurosurgical conditions are often incurable and lead to disability, severe physical symptoms, and distress for patients and families. Neurosurgeons may be responsible for transitioning management from curative to palliative. We sought to analyze the ethics of transitioning care from curative to palliative in patients in one's own specialty. Methods: This is a case-based narrative review. PubMed and Google Scholar were searched with no restrictions on date. Studies relevant to the topic were included. Results: We provide an introductory case. Then, we define the curative and palliative neurosurgical treatment paradigms, clarify the concept of transition of care from curative to palliative, and contrast generalist and specialist palliative care. Next, we provide an overview of core ethical principles. Then, we describe key considerations involved in transitioning patients from curative to palliative in one's own specialty, namely knowledge, communication, uncertainty, and futility. We then provide an analysis of the introductory case, highlighting the conflict of interest inherent in the transition. Conclusion: We conclude that it is acceptable for neurosurgeons and other specialists with adequate palliative care training to manage the transition in most cases, preferably as part of multidisciplinary care teams. While we discuss the example of neurosurgery in this manuscript, we emphasize that this analysis applies to other specialties where care transitions from curative to palliative intent occur. Across specialties, patient preferences and values are foundational in the timing and specifics of this transition.

http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.wneu.2022.10.003

Voir la revue «World neurosurgery, 168»

Autres numéros de la revue «World neurosurgery»

Consulter en ligne

Suggestions

Du même auteur

Ethics of transitioning from curative care to...

Article indépendant | SHLOBIN, Nathan A. | World neurosurgery | vol.168

Objective: Neurosurgical conditions are often incurable and lead to disability, severe physical symptoms, and distress for patients and families. Neurosurgeons may be responsible for transitioning management from curative to palli...

Ethics of transitioning from curative care to...

Article indépendant | SHLOBIN, Nathan A. | World neurosurgery | vol.168

Objective: Neurosurgical conditions are often incurable and lead to disability, severe physical symptoms, and distress for patients and families. Neurosurgeons may be responsible for transitioning management from curative to palli...

Neuropalliative care for the neurosurgeon : a...

Article | SHLOBIN, Nathan A. | Journal of neurosurgery

Many neurosurgical conditions are incurable, leading to disability or severe symptoms, poor quality of life, and distress for patients and families. The field of neuropalliative care (NPC) addresses the palliative care (PC) needs ...

De la même série

Ethics of transitioning from curative care to...

Article | SHLOBIN, Nathan A. | World neurosurgery | vol.168

Objective: Neurosurgical conditions are often incurable and lead to disability, severe physical symptoms, and distress for patients and families. Neurosurgeons may be responsible for transitioning management from curative to palli...

Clarity on palliative neurosurgery : a neuroe...

Article | BLACKSTONE, Eric C. | World neurosurgery

[Résumé à venir]

Palliative care consultation utilization amon...

Article | CHEN, W. | World neurosurgery

OBJECTIVE: In patients undergoing surgery for spinal metastasis, we sought to: 1) describe patterns of palliative care consultation, 2) evaluate the factors that trigger palliative care consultation, and 3) determine the associati...

Chargement des enrichissements...