When ‘Sanctity of Life’ and ‘Self-Determination’ clash : Briggs versus Briggs [2016] EWCOP 53 - implications for policy and practice

Article indépendant

KITZINGER, Jenny | KITZINGER, Celia | COWLEY, Jakki

In a landmark judgment in the English Court of Protection, the judge (Charles J) found it to be in the best interests of a minimally conscious patient for clinically assisted nutrition and hydration (CANH) to be withdrawn, with the inevitable consequence that the patient would die. In making this judgment, it was accepted that the patient's level of consciousness - if CANH were continued and rehabilitation provided - might improve, and that he might become capable of expressing emotions and making simple choices. The decision to withdraw treatment relied on a best interests decision, which gave great weight to the patient's past wishes, feelings, values and beliefs, and brought a 'holistic' approach to understanding what this particular patient would have wanted. We draw on our own experience of supporting families, advocating for patients and training healthcare professionals in similar situations to consider the implications of the published judgment for policy and practice with patients in prolonged disorders of consciousness and their families.

http://dx.doi.org/10.1136/medethics-2016-104118

Voir la revue «Journal of medical ethics, 43»

Autres numéros de la revue «Journal of medical ethics»

Consulter en ligne

Suggestions

Du même auteur

When ‘Sanctity of Life’ and ‘Self-Determinati...

Article indépendant | KITZINGER, Jenny | Journal of medical ethics | n°7 | vol.43

In a landmark judgment in the English Court of Protection, the judge (Charles J) found it to be in the best interests of a minimally conscious patient for clinically assisted nutrition and hydration (CANH) to be withdrawn, with t...

Causes and consequences of delays in treatmen...

Article | KITZINGER, Jenny | Journal of medical ethics | n°7 | vol.43

Life-extending treatment, in the form of artificial nutrition and hydration, is often provided to people in permanent vegetative states (PVS) in England and Wales for many years, even when their family believes the patient would n...

Causes and consequences of delays in treatmen...

Article indépendant | KITZINGER, Jenny | Journal of medical ethics | n°7 | vol.43

Life-extending treatment, in the form of artificial nutrition and hydration, is often provided to people in permanent vegetative states (PVS) in England and Wales for many years, even when their family believes the patient would n...

De la même série

Ethics briefing

Article indépendant | MICHAUX, Natalie | Journal of medical ethics | n°5 | vol.51

Spanish regulation of euthanasia and physicia...

Article indépendant | VELASCO SANZ, Tamara Raquel | Journal of medical ethics | n°1 | vol.49

In March 2021, the Spanish Congress approved the law regulating euthanasia, that regulates both euthanasia and physician-assisted suicide (PAS). In this article, we analyse the Spanish law regulating euthanasia and PAS, comparing ...

Implications of extended terminal sedation

Article indépendant | SORUM, Paul Clay | Journal of medical ethics | n°4 | vol.49

Gilbertson, Savulescu, Oakley and Wilkinson propose extending the availability of terminal sedation (TS) to patients with intractable pain and/or suffering who are expected to live more than 2 weeks (hence the designation of exten...

Expanded terminal sedation : dangerous waters

Article indépendant | RIISFELDT, Thomas David | Journal of medical ethics | n°4 | vol.49

Gilbertson et al should be commended for their insightful exploration of expanded terminal sedation (ETS)1; however, there are a number of concerns that I will address in this response. I will first better characterise the current...

Suffering, existential distress and temporali...

Article indépendant | EMMERICH, Nathan | Journal of medical ethics | n°4 | vol.49

While there is a great deal to agree with in the essay Expanded Terminal Sedation in End-of-Life Care there is, we think, a need to more fully appreciate the humanistic side of both palliative and end-of-life care. Not only does t...

Chargement des enrichissements...