Palliative care quality indicators in Italy : what do we evaluate?

Article indépendant

D'ANGELO, Daniela | MASTROIANNI, Chiara | VELLONE, Ercole | ALVARO, Rosaria | CASALE, Giuseppe | LATINA, Roberto | MARINIS, Maria Grazia de

Purpose: In recent years, the number of palliative service providers has increased significantly. This expansion necessitates an evaluation in order to provide the basis for quality improvement of the care. Policymakers, managers of palliative care programs, and others committed to the improvement of end-of-life care need methods and criteria to measure and evaluate the care delivered. As quality measurement is expensive and difficult to undertake, it is fundamental that quality measures evaluate the right things. Quality evaluation in Italy is supported by health authorities who have developed some indicators of palliative care. The aims of this study were to give an overview of these indicators. Methods: We analyzed all palliative care indicators developed by Italian national authorities from 2000 to the present. These indicators have been divided into three different levels of analysis (structure, process, and outcome). Subsequently, two reviewers have independently compared their degree of concordance with domains, and guidelines developed by the NCP for palliative care and after careful discussion an expert panel has elaborated a final consensus document. Results: Most of the quality indicators analyzed deal with the structure and process of palliative care, however they miss outcomes and do not cover domains mainly concerned with spiritual, ethical, cultural, or existential aspects of care. Conclusions: More attention should be paid to the development of outcome indicators of palliative care. The attempt to identify a group of indicators which cover every domain of palliative care represents a challenge for the future in terms of finding new cognitive models more oriented toward subjectivity.

http://dx.doi.org/10.1007/s00520-011-1301-y

Voir la revue «Supportive care in cancer, 20»

Autres numéros de la revue «Supportive care in cancer»

Consulter en ligne

Suggestions

Du même auteur

Palliative care quality indicators in Italy :...

Article indépendant | D'ANGELO, Daniela | Supportive care in cancer | n°9 | vol.20

Purpose: In recent years, the number of palliative service providers has increased significantly. This expansion necessitates an evaluation in order to provide the basis for quality improvement of the care. Policymakers, managers ...

Palliative care education in undergraduate nu...

Article | MASTROIANNI, Chiara | JOURNAL OF HOSPICE AND PALLIATIVE NURSING | n°1 | vol.21

Worldwide, more than 19 million people require palliative care because of an advanced stage of disease. Undergraduate nursing education should include palliative care as the European consensus suggests. In 2004, the European Socie...

Palliative care education in undergraduate nu...

Article indépendant | MASTROIANNI, Chiara | JOURNAL OF HOSPICE AND PALLIATIVE NURSING | n°1 | vol.21

Worldwide, more than 19 million people require palliative care because of an advanced stage of disease. Undergraduate nursing education should include palliative care as the European consensus suggests. In 2004, the European Socie...

De la même série

Social factors affecting home-based end-of-li...

Article indépendant | HIRAMOTO, Shuji | Supportive care in cancer | n°1 | vol.33

OBJECTIVE: This study aimed to explore the social factors of patients and caregivers, including those related to their wishes for home-based end-of-life care that influence its fulfillment. METHODS: A secondary analysis was conduc...

Effectiveness of family dignity intervention ...

Article indépendant | YANG, Cuiying | Supportive care in cancer | n°1 | vol.33

OBJECTIVES: This study explores the impact of family dignity interventions (FDI) on palliative patients and their family caregivers through a systematic review and meta-analysis of randomized controlled trials (RCTs). METHODS: A s...

Methodologies and characteristics of studies ...

Article indépendant | CHECHIRLIAN, Kevin | Supportive care in cancer | n°2 | vol.33

PURPOSE: Improvements in the treatment of advanced cancer have increased life expectancy but have also increased the costs to healthcare systems, patients and their families. A systematic review is needed to summarize research wor...

Advanced practice nurse-led early palliative ...

Article indépendant | LELOND, Stephanie | Supportive care in cancer | n°3 | vol.33

BACKGROUND: Although the benefits of early palliative care have been established in advanced cancers, there remains a lack of access to and poor uptake of these services. Barriers include healthcare provider attitudes, lack of sta...

Proactive symptom monitoring to initiate time...

Article indépendant | YANG, Grace Meijuan | Supportive care in cancer | n°3 | vol.33

PURPOSE: To deliver timely palliative care in response to supportive and palliative care needs as they arise, we developed a model called "Supportive and Palliative care Review Kit in Locations Everywhere" (SPARKLE), which compris...

Chargement des enrichissements...