An evaluation of the adequacy of Indian national and state essential medicines lists (EMLs) for palliative care medical need : a comparative analysis

Article

AGRAWAL, Disha | SHRINIVAS, Divya | SHARMA, Parth | RAJAGOPAL, Muttacaud Ramakrishnan | GHOSHAL, Arun | ZADEY, Siddhesh

OBJECTIVES: Essential medicines lists (EMLs) guide the public sector procurement and supply of medications to impact access to adequate and appropriate palliative care drugs. This study evaluates the adequacy of India's national and sub-national EMLs that can directly impact palliative care for 5.4 million patients. METHODS: In this qualitative document review, we compared Indian national, and state EMLs acquired from official government websites with the International Association for Hospice and Palliative Care (IAHPC) EML recommendations. We analysed data on the indication and formulation of drugs under the different categories of formulations present (all, some and no), and drugs absent. Literature review and inputs from palliative care experts provided alternatives of absent medications to assess the adequacy of lists in managing the symptoms listed by IAPHC. RESULTS: We analysed 3 national and 27 state lists for 33 recommended drugs. The Central Government Health Services list had the maximum availability of all formulations of drugs (16 [48%]) nationally. Among states and union territories, the Delhi EML was the closest to IAHPC with 17 (52%) drugs with all formulations present. Karnataka had the most incomplete EML with only 3 (9%) drugs with all formulations present. No EML had all the recommended formulations of morphine. In one national and seventeen state EMLs, oral morphine was absent. CONCLUSION: While Indian EMLs lack drugs for palliative care when compared with the IAHPC EML, symptom management is adequate. There is a need for countries with limited resources to modify the IAPHC list for their settings.

http://dx.doi.org/10.3332/ecancer.2025.1837

Voir la revue «Ecancermedicalscience, 19»

Autres numéros de la revue «Ecancermedicalscience»

Consulter en ligne

Suggestions

Du même auteur

An evaluation of the adequacy of Indian natio...

Article indépendant | AGRAWAL, Disha | Ecancermedicalscience | vol.19

OBJECTIVES: Essential medicines lists (EMLs) guide the public sector procurement and supply of medications to impact access to adequate and appropriate palliative care drugs. This study evaluates the adequacy of India's national a...

Palliative care for patients with cancer : AS...

Article indépendant | SANDERS, Justin J. | Journal of clinical oncology

PURPOSE: To provide evidence-based guidance to oncology clinicians, patients, nonprofessional caregivers, and palliative care clinicians to update the 2016 ASCO guideline on the integration of palliative care into standard oncolog...

Development and evaluation of an online train...

Article | PASSI, Varun Raj | BMC medical education | n°1 | vol.25

BACKGROUND: Palliative care training at the undergraduate level is poor in India. With the need for palliative care rising in India and globally, it is possible to train physicians in resource-limited settings in palliative care v...

De la même série

An evaluation of the adequacy of Indian natio...

Article | AGRAWAL, Disha | Ecancermedicalscience | vol.19

OBJECTIVES: Essential medicines lists (EMLs) guide the public sector procurement and supply of medications to impact access to adequate and appropriate palliative care drugs. This study evaluates the adequacy of India's national a...

Creating the evidence base for palliative car...

Article | NAMISANGO, Eve | Ecancermedicalscience | vol.18

BACKGROUND: The need for palliative care in cancer is highest in resource-limited settings given the high disease burden, which is projected to double by 2050, and late patient presentation. To stimulate service development and en...

Palliative and end-of-life care initiatives f...

Article | SALINS, Naveen | Ecancermedicalscience | vol.18

India is facing a growing burden of cancer, resulting in high cancer-associated mortality. However, the rise in cancer incidence is disproportionately high compared to access and provision of palliative care. This review aims to i...

Teaching empathy and compassion to healthcare...

Article | RAO, Seema Rajesh | Ecancermedicalscience | vol.18

Empathy and compassion are core competencies that healthcare providers (HCPs) require when caring for patients and families with life-threatening illnesses like cancer. These constructs are often challenging to define and generali...

Financial toxicity in cancer palliative care ...

Article | JOSHI, Saurabh | Ecancermedicalscience | vol.18

Financial toxicity (FT) places a significant burden on individuals undergoing cancer care, leading to emotional distress, social isolation and financial burnout. In India, the growing number of cancer cases and the ever-expanding ...

Chargement des enrichissements...