TIEC, trauma capacity, and the moral priority of surrogate decision makers in futility disputes

Article indépendant

FIESTER, Autumn

In the past 15 years, trauma-informed care (TIC) has evolved as a new paradigm in healthcare that recognizes the impact of past traumas on patients' and families' healthcare experience while seeking to avoid inducing new trauma during clinical care. A recent paper by Lanphier and Anani extends TIC principles to healthcare ethics consultation (HEC) in what they label "trauma-informed ethics consultation" (TIEC), which calls for the "addition of trauma informed awareness, training, and skill in clinical ethics consultation." While Lanphier and Anani claim that TIEC is "novel, but not radical" because it builds on the approach to HEC endorsed by the American Society for Bioethics and Humanities, I believe that TIEC has radical implications, particularly regarding ethical obligations to surrogate decision makers (SDMs). Given what I call the SDM's "trauma capacity," I argue that TIEC accords moral priority to SDMs over patients in certain types of end-of-life cases, particularly futility disputes, which is a radical departure from the conventional HEC approach to SDMs.

http://dx.doi.org/10.1086/733392

Voir la revue «The journal of clinical ethics, 36»

Autres numéros de la revue «The journal of clinical ethics»

Consulter en ligne

Suggestions

Du même auteur

Surrogate wars : the "best interest values" h...

Article | FIESTER, Autumn | HEC forum

Conflicts involving end-of-life care between healthcare providers (HCPs) and surrogate decision-makers (SDMs) have received sustained attention for more than a quarter of a century, with early studies demonstrating a frequency of ...

Surrogate wars : the "best interest values" h...

Article indépendant | FIESTER, Autumn | HEC forum

Conflicts involving end-of-life care between healthcare providers (HCPs) and surrogate decision-makers (SDMs) have received sustained attention for more than a quarter of a century, with early studies demonstrating a frequency of ...

TIEC, trauma capacity, and the moral priority...

Article | FIESTER, Autumn | The journal of clinical ethics | n°1 | vol.36

In the past 15 years, trauma-informed care (TIC) has evolved as a new paradigm in healthcare that recognizes the impact of past traumas on patients' and families' healthcare experience while seeking to avoid inducing new trauma du...

De la même série

TIEC, trauma capacity, and the moral priority...

Article indépendant | FIESTER, Autumn | The journal of clinical ethics | n°1 | vol.36

In the past 15 years, trauma-informed care (TIC) has evolved as a new paradigm in healthcare that recognizes the impact of past traumas on patients' and families' healthcare experience while seeking to avoid inducing new trauma du...

Should providers engage in religious discussi...

Article indépendant | HOWE, Edmund G. | The journal of clinical ethics | n°4 | vol.35

Patients' spiritual views and, more generally, the meaning they feel in their lives is often, if not always, most important to them, especially when they have serious illness. Yet there are no standard requirements for providers t...

A wider understanding of a patient's relation...

Article indépendant | SIDDIQUI, Shahla | The journal of clinical ethics | n°1 | vol.33

Respect for autonomy is a key concept in contemporary bioethics and in ethics at the end of life in particular. An individualistic interpretation of autonomy may not incorporate the aspects of consideration that patients may have ...

Video messages : a tool to improve surrogate ...

Article indépendant | VITCOV, Giselle G. | The journal of clinical ethics | n°1 | vol.33

Advance directives (ADs) offer the opportunity for patients to express their desires regarding medical care in advance of any form of incapacitation. However, the efficacy of ADs in achieving care that aligns with patients' prefer...

Ethical considerations in supporting donation...

Article indépendant | TESTA, Giuliano | The journal of clinical ethics | n°3 | vol.33

There is a conflict between the wishes of terminally ill patients to allow withdrawal of treatment and become donors after cardiac death (DCD) and the limit on interventions required by the dead-donor rule (DDR). Once a breathing ...

Chargement des enrichissements...