Can depressed patients make a decision to request voluntary assisted dying?

Article

HOLMES, Alex | LANGE, Peter | STEWART, Cameron | WHITE, Ben | WILLMOTT, Lindy | DOOLEY, Michael | PHILIP, Jennifer | LA BROOY, Camille | KOMESAROFF, Paul

Depressive symptoms, including those as part of a major depressive disorder, are common at the end of life. A number of psychiatrists consider that a diagnosis of major depression precludes the capacity to make a decision to request voluntary assisted dying (VAD), although this is not a unanimous view. This paper uses a case of a patient in which two different psychiatric opinions were formed regarding her capacity to make the decision to request VAD. The difference of view can be related to whether major depression was diagnosed and the association made between depression and the capacity to request VAD. The view that an absence of major depression is required in order to establish the capacity to request VAD is potentially at odds with the legal definition and not necessarily in keeping with the patient's experience at the end of life.

http://dx.doi.org/10.1111/imj.15512

Voir la revue «Internal medicine journal, 51»

Autres numéros de la revue «Internal medicine journal»

Consulter en ligne

Suggestions

Du même auteur

Can depressed patients make a decision to req...

Article indépendant | HOLMES, Alex | Internal medicine journal | n°10 | vol.51

Depressive symptoms, including those as part of a major depressive disorder, are common at the end of life. A number of psychiatrists consider that a diagnosis of major depression precludes the capacity to make a decision to reque...

Can depressed patients make a decision to req...

Article indépendant | HOLMES, Alex | Internal medicine journal | n°10 | vol.51

Depressive symptoms, including those as part of a major depressive disorder, are common at the end of life. A number of psychiatrists consider that a diagnosis of major depression precludes the capacity to make a decision to reque...

Choreographing a good death : carers' experie...

Article indépendant | LEWIS, Sophie | Sociology of health and illness

The proliferation of assisted dying legislative reforms globally is a significant change in the social and medico-legal landscape of end-of-life care. Understanding the impacts of these legislative reforms on family members who ca...

De la même série

The conveyor belt for older people nearing th...

Article | HILLMAN, Ken | Internal medicine journal | n°8 | vol.54

The current fallback position for the elderly frail nearing the end of life (less than 12 months to live) is hospitalisation. There is a reluctance to use the term 'terminally ill' for this population, resulting in overtreatment, ...

The AMA supports all doctors in relation to v...

Article | KHORSHID, Omar | Internal medicine journal | n°6 | vol.52

This article outlines the Australian Medical Association's (AMA) current policy on voluntary assisted dying (VAD), arguing that, when read in good faith in its entirety as intended, the policy lacks neutrality or balance. As writt...

Voluntary assisted dying : peak bodies must p...

Article | CLOSE, Eliana | Internal medicine journal | n°6 | vol.52

Despite widespread reform in Australia, the Australian Medical Association (AMA) remains ethically opposed to voluntary assisted dying (VAD). This article argues that the AMA should abandon its opposition to VAD to fulfil better i...

Negative media portrayal of palliative care :...

Article | KIS-RIGO, Andrew | Internal medicine journal | n°8 | vol.51

Key misunderstandings of palliative care exist in the community, with media being reported as a key source underpinning knowledge. This retrospective media analysis of consecutive articles sought to examine the portrayal of pallia...

Can depressed patients make a decision to req...

Article | HOLMES, Alex | Internal medicine journal | n°10 | vol.51

Depressive symptoms, including those as part of a major depressive disorder, are common at the end of life. A number of psychiatrists consider that a diagnosis of major depression precludes the capacity to make a decision to reque...

Chargement des enrichissements...