Effects of prognostic communication strategies on emotions, coping, and appreciation of consultations : an experimental study in advanced cancer

Article indépendant

VAN DER VELDEN, Naomi C. A. | SMETS, Ellen M. A. | VAN VLIET, Liesbeth M. | BROM, Linda | VAN LAARHOVEN, Hanneke W. M. | HENSELMANS, Inge

OBJECTIVES: We aimed to investigate effects of prognostic communication strategies on emotions, coping, and appreciation of consultations in advanced cancer. METHODS: For this experimental study, we created 8 videos of a scripted oncological consultation, only varying in prognostic communication strategies. Disease-naive individuals (n = 1036) completed surveys before and after watching 1 video, while imagining being the depicted cancer patient. We investigated effects of the type of disclosure (prognostic disclosure vs. communication of unpredictability vs. non-disclosure) and content of disclosure (standard vs. standard and best-case vs. standard, best- and worst-case survival scenarios; numerical vs. word-based estimates) on emotions, coping, and appreciation of consultations. Moderating effects of individual characteristics were tested. RESULTS: Participants generally reported more satisfaction (p < .001) after prognostic disclosure versus communication of unpredictability and less uncertainty (p = .042), more satisfaction (p = .005), and more desirability (p = .016) regarding prognostic information after numerical versus word-based estimates. Effects of different survival scenarios were absent. Prognostic communication strategies lacked effects on emotions and coping. Significant moderators included prognostic information preference and uncertainty tolerance. SIGNIFICANCE OF RESULTS: In an experimental setting, prognostic disclosure does not cause more negative emotions than non-disclosure and numerical estimates are more strongly appreciated than words. Oncologists' worries about harming patients should not preclude disclosing (precise) prognostic information, yet sensitivity to individual preferences and characteristics remains pivotal.

http://dx.doi.org/10.1017/S1478951524000403

Voir la revue «Palliative & Supportive Care»

Autres numéros de la revue «Palliative & Supportive Care»

Consulter en ligne

Suggestions

Du même auteur

Effects of prognostic communication strategie...

Article indépendant | VAN DER VELDEN, Naomi C. A. | JOURNAL OF PAIN AND SYMPTOM MANAGEMENT

CONTEXT: Evidence-based guidance for oncologists on how to communicate prognosis is scarce. OBJECTIVES: To investigate the effects of prognostic communication strategies (prognostic disclosure vs. communication of unpredictability...

Effects of prognostic communication strategie...

Article indépendant | VAN DER VELDEN, Naomi C. A. | JOURNAL OF PAIN AND SYMPTOM MANAGEMENT

CONTEXT: Evidence-based guidance for oncologists on how to communicate prognosis is scarce. OBJECTIVES: To investigate the effects of prognostic communication strategies (prognostic disclosure vs. communication of unpredictability...

The effect of prognostic communication on pat...

Article | VAN DER VELDEN, Naomi C. A. | Current treatment options in oncology | n°5 | vol.21

BACKGROUND: While prognostic information is considered important for treatment decision-making, physicians struggle to communicate prognosis to advanced cancer patients. This systematic review aimed to offer up-to-date, evidence-b...

De la même série

PACOPED QL : development and evaluation of th...

Article indépendant | RIERA-NEGRE, Laia | Palliative & Supportive Care | vol.23

OBJECTIVES: This study aims to validate the Palliative and Complex Chronic Pediatric Patients QoL Inventory (PACOPED QL), a new quality-of-life (QoL) assessment tool for pediatric palliative patients with complex chronic condition...

Communicating about the end of life : the pat...

Article indépendant | D'ANDRIA URSOLEO, Jacopo | Palliative & Supportive Care | vol.23

Patients with cancer are surviving longer, and therefore have more time both living as well as for end-of-life (EOL) planning (Bergenholtz et al. Reference Bergenholtz, Missel and Timm2020). Major concerns for dying patients relat...

Advance care planning readiness, barriers, an...

Article indépendant | HOWE, Rebecca | Palliative & Supportive Care | vol.23

OBJECTIVES: Advance care planning (ACP) supports communication and medical decision-making and is best conceptualized as part of the care planning continuum. Black older adults have lower ACP engagement and poorer quality of care ...

SAHD-10 : development and initial validation ...

Article indépendant | KREMEIKE, Kerstin | Palliative & Supportive Care | vol.23

OBJECTIVES: Wishes to hasten death (WTHDs) are common in patients with serious illness. The Schedule of Attitudes Toward Hastened Death (SAHD) is a validated 20-item instrument for measuring WTHD. Two short versions have also been...

Teaching death, spirituality, and palliative ...

Article indépendant | CORPUZ, Jeff Clyde G. | Palliative & Supportive Care | vol.23

Teaching death, spirituality, and palliative care equips students with critical skills and perspectives for holistic patient care. This interdisciplinary approach fosters empathy, resilience, and personal growth while enhancing co...

Chargement des enrichissements...