Causal inference in case of near‐violation of positivity: comparison of methods

0 avis

Causal inference in case of near‐violation of positivity: comparison of methods

Archive ouverte

International audience. In causal studies, the near‐violation of the positivity may occur by chance, because of sample‐to‐sample fluctuation despite the theoretical veracity of the positivity assumption in the population. It may mostly happen when the exposure prevalence is low or when the sample size is small. We aimed to compare the robustness of g‐computation (GC), inverse probability weighting (IPW), truncated IPW, targeted maximum likelihood estimation (TMLE), and truncated TMLE in this situation, using simulations and one real application. We also tested different extrapolation situations for the sub‐group with a positivity violation. The results illustrated that the near‐violation of the positivity impacted all methods. We demonstrated the robustness of GC and TMLE‐based methods. Truncation helped in limiting the bias in near‐violation situations, but at the cost of bias in normal conditions. The application illustrated the variability of the results between the methods and the importance of choosing the most appropriate one. In conclusion, compared to propensity score‐based methods, methods based on outcome regression should be preferred when suspecting near‐violation of the positivity assumption.

Langue: en

Indexation

Consulter en ligne

Consulter le document

Suggestions

Du même auteur

G-computation, propensity score-based methods, and targeted maximum likelihood estimator for causal inference with different covariates sets: a comparative simulation study

Archive ouverte | Chatton, Arthur | CCSD

International audience. Controlling for confounding bias is crucial in causal inference. Distinct methods are currently employed to mitigate the effects of confounding bias. Each requires the introduction of a set o...

Identification of in-sample positivity violations using regression trees: The PoRT algorithm

Archive ouverte | Danelian, Gabriel | CCSD

International audience. BackgroundThe positivity assumption is crucial when drawing causal inferences from observational studies, but it is often overlooked in practice. A violation of positivity occurs when the sam...

G-computation and machine learning for estimating the causal effects of binary exposure statuses on binary outcomes

Archive ouverte | Le Borgne, F | CCSD

International audience. Abstract In clinical research, there is a growing interest in the use of propensity score-based methods to estimate causal effects. G-computation is an alternative because of its high statist...

Chargement des enrichissements...