Power asymmetries in social networks of ecosystem services governance

Archive ouverte

Vallet, Améline | Locatelli, Bruno | Barnaud, Cécile | Makowski, David | Quispe Conde, Yésica | Levrel, Harold

Edité par CCSD ; Elsevier -

International audience. Power asymmetries affect the governance of natural resources but are rarely considered explicitly in ecosystem services research, which often overlooks the diversity of actors and their interactions. In this paper, we propose an innovative and easily replicable method to analyze two types of power asymmetries, using social network analysis and a power typology which distinguishes between influence and domination. We apply this method to a network of actors involved in the governance of eight ecosystem services in the Peruvian Andes. The results reveal substantial power asymmetries, of different types. Indirect managers of ecosystem services had higher influence and domination than the direct managers and beneficiaries. Businesses showed significantly lower influence than members of civil society, non-governmental organizations, and the public sector (state or decentralized organizations, public enterprises). Compared to other actors, members of the public sector had significantly higher domination, especially national actors. Domination and influence relationships strongly increased conflict probability, along with difference of domination score between two actors. A better interdisciplinary understanding of the determinants of power asymmetries can make the governance of socio-ecological systems more sustainable.

Suggestions

Du même auteur

Power asymmetries in ecosystem services governance: insights from social network analysis

Archive ouverte | Vallet, Améline | CCSD

International audience. Understanding how power asymmetries arise and how they can affect policy outcomes are crucial questions for ecosystem services (ES) research. In political sciences and sociology, the distribu...

Knowledge coproduction to improve assessments of nature's contributions to people

Archive ouverte | Vallet, Améline | CCSD

International audience. Sustainability science needs new approaches to produce, share, and use knowledge because there are major barriers to translating research into policy and practice. Multiple actors hold releva...

Linking equity, power and stakeholders' roles in relation to ecosystem services

Archive ouverte | Vallet, Améline | CCSD

International audience. The issues of power and equity are gaining attention in the research on ecosystem services (ES). Stakeholders who benefit from ES are not necessarily able or authorized to participate in ES m...

Chargement des enrichissements...