Structure and integration of specialty palliative care in three NCI-designated cancer centers : a mixed methods case study

Article indépendant

SCHIFFERDECKER, Karen E. | BUTCHER, Rebecca L. | MURRAY, Genevra F. | KNUTZEN, Kristin E. | KAPADIA, Nirav S. | BROOKS, Gabriel A. | WASP, Garrett T. | EGGLY, Susan | HANSON, Laura C. | ROCQUE, Gabrielle B. | PERRY, Amanda N. | BARNATO, Amber E.

INTRODUCTION: Early access to specialty palliative care is associated with better quality of life, less intensive end-of-life treatment and improved outcomes for patients with advanced cancer. However, significant variation exists in implementation and integration of palliative care. This study compares the organizational, sociocultural, and clinical factors that support or hinder palliative care integration across three U.S. cancer centers using an in-depth mixed methods case study design and proposes a middle range theory to further characterize specialty palliative care integration. METHODS: Mixed methods data collection included document review, semi-structured interviews, direct clinical observation, and context data related to site characteristics and patient demographics. A mixed inductive and deductive approach and triangulation was used to analyze and compare sites' palliative care delivery models, organizational structures, social norms, and clinician beliefs and practices. RESULTS: Sites included an urban center in the Midwest and two in the Southeast. Data included 62 clinician and 27 leader interviews, observations of 410 inpatient and outpatient encounters and seven non-encounter-based meetings, and multiple documents. Two sites had high levels of "favorable" organizational influences for specialty palliative care integration, including screening, policies, and other structures facilitating integration of specialty palliative care into advanced cancer care. The third site lacked formal organizational policies and structures for specialty palliative care, had a small specialty palliative care team, espoused an organizational identity linked to treatment innovation, and demonstrated strong social norms for oncologist primacy in decision making. This combination led to low levels of specialty palliative care integration and greater reliance on individual clinicians to initiate palliative care. CONCLUSION: Integration of specialty palliative care services in advanced cancer care was associated with a complex interaction of organization-level factors, social norms, and individual clinician orientation. The resulting middle range theory suggests that formal structures and policies for specialty palliative care combined with supportive social norms are associated with greater palliative care integration in advanced cancer care, and less influence of individual clinician preferences or tendencies to continue treatment. These results suggest multi-faceted efforts at different levels, including social norms, may be needed to improve specialty palliative care integration for advanced cancer patients.

http://dx.doi.org/10.1186/s12904-023-01182-9

Voir la revue «BMC palliative care, 22»

Autres numéros de la revue «BMC palliative care»

Consulter en ligne

Suggestions

Du même auteur

Structure and integration of specialty pallia...

Article indépendant | SCHIFFERDECKER, Karen E. | BMC palliative care | n°1 | vol.22

INTRODUCTION: Early access to specialty palliative care is associated with better quality of life, less intensive end-of-life treatment and improved outcomes for patients with advanced cancer. However, significant variation exists...

Role of norms in variation in cancer centers'...

Article | KNUTZEN, Kristin E. | BMC palliative care | n°1 | vol.19

BACKGROUND: A critical barrier to improving the quality of end-of-life (EOL) cancer care is our lack of understanding of the mechanisms underlying variation in EOL treatment intensity. This study aims to fill this gap by identifyi...

Role of norms in variation in cancer centers'...

Article indépendant | KNUTZEN, Kristin E. | BMC palliative care | n°1 | vol.19

BACKGROUND: A critical barrier to improving the quality of end-of-life (EOL) cancer care is our lack of understanding of the mechanisms underlying variation in EOL treatment intensity. This study aims to fill this gap by identifyi...

De la même série

Translation, cross-cultural adaptation and va...

Article indépendant | XIE, Zhishan | BMC palliative care | n°1 | vol.24

INTRODUCTION: People diagnosed with cancer are the most frequent users of palliative care. However, there are no specific standards for early identifying patients with palliative care needs in mainland China. The Supportive and Pa...

Validation of the advance care planning engag...

Article indépendant | TAN, Gwendoline Wan Hua | BMC palliative care | n°1 | vol.24

BACKGROUND: Singapore has an ageing population. End-of-life care and advance care planning are becoming increasingly important. To assess advance care planning engagement, valid tools are required. The primary objective of the stu...

A relational approach to co-create advance ca...

Article indépendant | PHENWAN, Tharin | BMC palliative care | n°1 | vol.24

BACKGROUND: Discussing Advance Care Planning (ACP) with people living with dementia (PwD) is challenging due to topic sensitivity, fluctuating mental capacity and symptom of forgetfulness. Given communication difficulties, the pre...

Learning from experience : does providing end...

Article indépendant | MEIER, Clément | BMC palliative care | n°1 | vol.24

BACKGROUND: Despite the critical role of health literacy in utilizing palliative care and engaging in advance care planning, limited research exists on the determinants of end-of-life health literacy. This study investigates the a...

A study protocol for individualized prognosti...

Article indépendant | VAN DEN BESSELAAR, Boyd Noël | BMC palliative care | n°1 | vol.24

BACKGROUND: Head and neck squamous cell cancer (HNSCC) has a poor prognosis, with approximately 25-30% of patients transitioning into the palliative phase at some point. The length of this phase is relatively short, with a median ...

Chargement des enrichissements...