Family experience of palliative sedation therapy : proportional vs. continuous deep sedation

Article indépendant

IMAI, Kengo | MORITA, Tatsuya | MORI, Masanori | YOKOMICHI, Naosuke | YAMAUCHI, Toshihiro | MIWA, Satoru | INOUE, Satoshi | NAITO, Akemi Shirado | MASUKAWA, Kento | KIZAWA, Yoshiyuki | TSUNETO, Satoru | SHIMA, Yasuo | OTANI, Hiroyuki | MIYASHITA, Mitsunori

Purpose: Some patients experience intense symptoms refractory to intensive palliative care, and palliative sedation is sometimes used. Palliative sedation may be classified into proportional and continuous deep sedation (CDS). The primary aim of this study was to compare family experience between families of patients who received proportional or CDS. Methods: A multicenter questionnaire survey was conducted involving bereaved families of cancer patients who received proportional or CDS based on a sedation protocol. Overall evaluation of sedation (satisfaction, family-perceived distress, appropriateness of timing, and patient distress) and 13-item family concerns, good death, satisfaction with care, depression, quality of care, unfinished business, and balance between symptom relief and maintaining communication were measured. Results: Among the 2120 patients who died, 222 patients received a continuous infusion of midazolam. A sedation protocol was used in 147 patients, and questionnaires were sent to 124 families. A total of 78 responses were finally returned (proportional, 58 vs. CDS, 20). There were no significant differences in the overall evaluation, family concerns, total score of good death, satisfaction, depression, or balance between symptom relief and maintaining communication. On the other hand, some quality of care items, i.e., relationship with medical staff (P < 0.01), physical care by nurses (P = 0.04), and coordination and consistency (P = 0.04), were significantly better in the CDS group than in the proportional sedation group. Family-reported unfinished business was also better in the CDS group, with marginal significance. Conclusions: Family experience of CDS was not less favorable than proportional sedation, and actually rated more favorably for some elements of quality of care and unfinished business.

http://dx.doi.org/10.1007/s00520-021-06745-1

Voir la revue «Supportive care in cancer»

Autres numéros de la revue «Supportive care in cancer»

Consulter en ligne

Suggestions

Du même auteur

Family experience of palliative sedation ther...

Article | IMAI, Kengo | Supportive care in cancer

Purpose: Some patients experience intense symptoms refractory to intensive palliative care, and palliative sedation is sometimes used. Palliative sedation may be classified into proportional and continuous deep sedation (CDS). The...

Family experience of palliative sedation ther...

Article indépendant | IMAI, Kengo | Supportive care in cancer

Purpose: Some patients experience intense symptoms refractory to intensive palliative care, and palliative sedation is sometimes used. Palliative sedation may be classified into proportional and continuous deep sedation (CDS). The...

Comparative study of clinicians' and family m...

Article | SUZUKI, Kozue | BMJ supportive & palliative care

Objective: End-of-life experiences (ELEs), such as deathbed visions (DBVs), have been reported worldwide. However, ELEs have rarely been discussed in clinical practice, possibly because of the different perceptions of ELEs among c...

De la même série

Social factors affecting home-based end-of-li...

Article indépendant | HIRAMOTO, Shuji | Supportive care in cancer | n°1 | vol.33

OBJECTIVE: This study aimed to explore the social factors of patients and caregivers, including those related to their wishes for home-based end-of-life care that influence its fulfillment. METHODS: A secondary analysis was conduc...

Effectiveness of family dignity intervention ...

Article indépendant | YANG, Cuiying | Supportive care in cancer | n°1 | vol.33

OBJECTIVES: This study explores the impact of family dignity interventions (FDI) on palliative patients and their family caregivers through a systematic review and meta-analysis of randomized controlled trials (RCTs). METHODS: A s...

Methodologies and characteristics of studies ...

Article indépendant | CHECHIRLIAN, Kevin | Supportive care in cancer | n°2 | vol.33

PURPOSE: Improvements in the treatment of advanced cancer have increased life expectancy but have also increased the costs to healthcare systems, patients and their families. A systematic review is needed to summarize research wor...

Advanced practice nurse-led early palliative ...

Article indépendant | LELOND, Stephanie | Supportive care in cancer | n°3 | vol.33

BACKGROUND: Although the benefits of early palliative care have been established in advanced cancers, there remains a lack of access to and poor uptake of these services. Barriers include healthcare provider attitudes, lack of sta...

Proactive symptom monitoring to initiate time...

Article indépendant | YANG, Grace Meijuan | Supportive care in cancer | n°3 | vol.33

PURPOSE: To deliver timely palliative care in response to supportive and palliative care needs as they arise, we developed a model called "Supportive and Palliative care Review Kit in Locations Everywhere" (SPARKLE), which compris...

Chargement des enrichissements...