"It is difficult to be absolutely sure one way or the other." - a mixed method study on Finnish physicians' views on euthanasia and physician-assisted suicide

Article indépendant

PIILI, Reetta P. | HOKKA, Minna | TOLVANEN, Elina | VANSKA, Jukka | LOUHIALA, Pekka | LEHTO, Juho T.

BACKGROUND: Euthanasia and physician-assisted suicide (PAS) are complex and ethically challenging topics. Physicians' attitudes toward euthanasia and PAS have been studied, but little is known about their ethical considerations regarding these topics. This study aimed to assess Finnish physicians' views on assisted dying (AD), including euthanasia and PAS. Our special emphasis was to describe physicians' views on the legalization of AD, their views on AD as a phenomenon, and how AD reflects on physicians' roles. METHODS: A survey including statements and open questions concerning euthanasia and PAS was sent to all Finnish physicians in 2020. The data was analysed using quantitative measures and a qualitative approach. RESULTS: Altogether, 6889 physicians answered the survey, yielding a response rate of 26%. Of the responders, 9% fully agreed that accepting euthanasia would benefit the physician-patient relationship, while 19% fully agreed that it would harm this relationship. From 2565 responders, 3033 answers were received to the open questions. The qualitative analysis yielded two unifying categories, firstly ‘Physicians’ views on assisted dying (AD) in the current societal situation and on its legalization’ included three main categories namely: ‘AD and end-of-life issues in the current societal situation’ (f = 230), ‘Physicians perspectives on legalisation of AD’ (f = 605) and ‘The possible consequences of legalizing AD’ (f = 543). Secondly, the unifying category ‘Physicians views on AD as part of their work and as a phenomenon’ included two main categories, ‘AD and the physicians’ professional role (f = 650) and ‘AD as a multifaceted phenomenon’ (f = 296). CONCLUSION: Assisted dying is seen as a complex issue, and it was difficult to form an opinion on it. Physicians and the care team are faced with ethical dilemmas about topics related to AD, even though it is not legalized in Finland. Open and pluralistic discussion on AD, including ethical aspects, implications for society and end-of-life care practices is of utmost importance.

http://dx.doi.org/10.1186/s12910-025-01220-6

Voir la revue «BMC medical ethics, 26»

Autres numéros de la revue «BMC medical ethics»

Consulter en ligne

Suggestions

Du même auteur

Facing a request for assisted death - views o...

Article indépendant | PIILI, Reetta P. | BMC medical ethics | n°1 | vol.25

BACKGROUND: Assisted death, including euthanasia and physician-assisted suicide (PAS), is under debate worldwide, and these practices are adopted in many Western countries. Physicians' attitudes toward assisted death vary across t...

Content validity of the questionnaire conside...

Article indépendant | TOLVANEN, Elina | Scientific reports | n°1 | vol.14

Despite numerous surveys conducted across the world considering assisted death, content validity evaluations of the survey questionnaires are seldom published. Likewise, there is no previous research about the content validity of ...

Content validity of the questionnaire conside...

Article indépendant | TOLVANEN, Elina | Scientific reports | n°1 | vol.14

Despite numerous surveys conducted across the world considering assisted death, content validity evaluations of the survey questionnaires are seldom published. Likewise, there is no previous research about the content validity of ...

De la même série

Students' attitudes toward euthanasia and abo...

Article indépendant | TUTIC GROKSA, Ivana | BMC medical ethics | n°1 | vol.26

INTRODUCTION: Abortion and euthanasia are still one of the greatest bioethical challenges. Previous studies have shown that there are differences in attitudes towards these issues depending on socio-demographic characteristics and...

Disparity in attitudes regarding assisted dyi...

Article indépendant | TAKIMOTO, Yoshiyuki | BMC medical ethics | n°1 | vol.26

BACKGROUND: Recently, an increasing number of countries have been allowing voluntary active euthanasia (VAE) and physician-assisted suicide (PAS) as part of palliative care. Japan stands out as the most aged country in the develop...

Lay views in southern France of the acceptabi...

Article indépendant | MUNOZ SASTRE, María Teresa | BMC medical ethics | n°1 | vol.26

AIM: To carry out a detailed study of existing positions in the French public of the acceptability of refusing treatment because of alleged futility, and to try to link these to people's age, gender, and religious practice. METHOD...

Ethical issues raised in the care of the elde...

Article indépendant | BOUCHLAGHEM, Mohamed Amine | BMC medical ethics | n°1 | vol.26

BACKGROUND: The COVID-19 pandemic has led governments worldwide to make ethically controversial decisions. As a result, healthcare professionals are facing several ethical dilemmas, especially in terms of healthcare services provi...

Physicians' moral distinctions between medica...

Article indépendant | MATTHEW, Midori | BMC medical ethics | n°1 | vol.26

BACKGROUND: Medical assistance in dying (MAiD) was legalized in Canada following the Carter v. Canada ruling of 2015. In spite of legalization, the ethics of MAiD remain contentious. The bioethical literature has attempted to diff...

Chargement des enrichissements...