Comparison of surgical management and outcomes of acute right colic and sigmoid diverticulitis: a French national retrospective cohort study
Archive ouverte
Karam, E. | Sabbagh, C. | Beyer-Bergeot, L. | Zerbib, P. | Bridoux, V. | Manceau, G. | Panis, Y. | Buscail, E. | Venara, A. | Khaoudy, I. | Gaillard, M. | Viennet, M. | Thobie, A. | Menahem, B. | Eveno, C. | Bonnel, C. | Mabrut, J.-Y. | Badic, B. | Godet, C. | Eid, Y. | Duchalais, E. | Lakkis, Z. | Cotte, E. | Laforest, A. | Desfourneaux, V. | Maggiori, L. | Rebibo, L. | Christou, N. | Talal, A. | Aubert, M. | Bonnamy, C. | Germain, A. | Mauvais, F. | Tresallet, C. | Roudie, J. | Laurent, A. | Trilling, B. | Bertrand, M. | Massalou, D. | Romain, B. | Tranchart, H. | Giger-Pabst, U. | Alves, A. | Ouaissi, M. | Pellegrin, Alexandra | Regimbeau, Jean Marc | Gillet, Julien | Hamy, Antoine | Lahmidi, Amine | Sebbagh, Mohamed | Bres, Antoine | Girard, Nicolas | Desjouis, Aurélie | Ainseba, Nadjib | Epailly, Julien | Huysman, Fabienne | Dezeustre, Maud | Doussot, Alexandre | Turco, Célia | Bourrhis, Diane | Godet, Camille | Finocchi, Morgane | Marion, Yoan | Lebreton, Gil | Benard, Flavie | Pineau, Elodie | Bouvier, Véronique | Dejardin, Olivier | Viennet, Manon | Moreno-Lopez, Nathan | Rat, Patrick | Makar, Bassem | Fara, Paola | Pompilio, Marc | Hertault, Hugo | Guezennec, Corentin | Saida, Habchi | Brinza, Alexandre | Plard, Laurent | Ailhaud, Antoine | Gutierrez, Léa | Venchiarutti, Vincent | Faucheron, Jean-Luc | Morin, Bertrand | de la Clause, Bertrand Pech | Voitellier, Eglantine | Gagnat, Guillaume | Noiret, Barbara | Laroye, Constance | Piessen, Guillaume | Lécolle, Katia | Robert, Jean | Engel, Perrine | Mathonnet, Muriel | Rodriguez, Cyprien | Makki, Ammar | Couchard, Anne-Cécile | Duramé, François | Marceau, Cécile | Paquet, Jean-Christophe | Kepenekian, Vahan | Passot, Guillaume | Glehen, Olivier | Wallach, Ninon | Mohkam, Kayvan | Blanc, Marie-Caroline | Berdah, Stéphane | Mege, Diane | Ayav, Ahmet | Chanty, Hervé | Didier, Alexandre | Vigneron, Estelle | Périard, Noémie | Thaumoux, Marie | Grenouilloux, Océane | Fall, Seila | Thomareis, Sophoclis | Marsollier, Chloé | Prud’homme, Michel | Antonopulos, Christos | Msika, Simon | Monsinjon, Marie | Giacca, Massimo | Cazelles, Antoine | Karoui, Mehdi | Malerba, Valentina | Dagher, Ibrahim | de Angelis, Nicola | Brunetti, Francesco | Ahmed, Omar | Ferraz, Jean-Marc | Ramjaun, Yassir | Denet, Christine | Fuchs, Basile | Pietrasz, Daniel | Raimbert, Pénélope | Benedetti, Juliette | Coton, Chloé | Corte, Hélène | Medrignac, Aude | Chavrier, Daphné | Girard, Robin | Berthelot, Julia | Monge, Matthieu | Papet, Eloïse | Pinson, Jean | Dolbeau, Elise | Tuech, Jean-Jacques | Chautard, Julien | Boullier, Mathilde | Goujard, François | Perrot, Laurent | Loge, Ludovic | Petiot, Jean-Michel | Mandefredelli, Simone | Charleux-Muller, Diane | Sauvinet, Guillaume | Bertin, Jean-Baptiste | Vincent, Louis | Simeu, Blandine | Delhorme, Jean-Baptiste | Brigand, Cécile | Rohr, Serge | Bouchet, Manon | Duffas, Jean-Pierre | Ghouti, Laurent | Philis, Antoine | Portier, Guillaume | Michot, Nicolas | Artus, Alice | Mauny, Emilien | Jouppe, Pierre-Olivier | Bourbao-Tournois, Céline | Barbin, Hugo | Thiery, Julien
Edité par
CCSD ; Springer Verlag (Germany) -
International audience.
Background: Acute right colic diverticulitis (ARD) is less frequent in Western countries than acute sigmoid diverticulitis (ASD). We aimed to compare the management of ARD and ASD operated on in emergency.Methods: All consecutive patients who had emergency surgery for ASD and ARD (2010-2021) were included in a retrospective, multicenter, cohort study. Patients were identified from databases in French centers that were members of the French Surgical Association. Emergency surgery was performed during the same hospitalization for peritonitis or after failure of conservative treatment. Early and late postoperative outcomes were studied.Results: A total of 2297 patients were included with 2256 (98.2%) ASD and 41 (1.8%) ARD patients. Baseline characteristics were similar. Overall, patients were rated Hinchey 3-4 (63.9%, n = 1468, p = 0.287). ARD was more often treated with resection and anastomosis, protected or not (53.7%, n = 22), whereas ASD was mainly treated with resection and terminal ostomy (62.5% (n = 1409), p < 0.001). Median operative time was shorter for ARD (120 vs 146 min, p = 0.04). The group of ARD patients showed a higher prevalence of Clavien III/IV complications compared to the group of ASD patients, although no statistically significant difference was observed (41.5%, n = 17 vs. 27.6%, n = 620, p = 0.054). However 90-day mortality only happened in ASD patients (9.8%, n = 223 vs 0, p = 0.03). ARD patients had more diverticulitis recurrence (46.3%, n = 19 vs 13.4%, n = 303, p < 0.001). Multivariate analysis identified female sex as a protective factor for recurrence [odds ratio (OR) 0.55, p < 0.001] and ARD as a risk factor (OR 8.85, p < 0.001).Conclusion: Operated on in emergency, ARDs have more resection anastomosis, with a similar rate of complications, less mortality, and more recurrence of diverticulitis than ASD.
