A conceptual justification for brain death

Article indépendant

BERNAT, James L.

Among the old and new controversies over brain death, none is more fundamental than whether brain death is equivalent to the biological phenomenon of human death. Here, I defend this equivalency by offering a brief conceptual justification for this view of brain death, a subject that Andrew Huang and I recently analyzed elsewhere in greater detail. My defense of the concept of brain death has evolved since Bernard Gert, Charles Culver, and I first addressed it in 1981, a development that paralleled advances in intensive care unit treatment. The century-old concept of the organism as a whole provides the fundamental justification for the equivalency of brain death and human death. In our technological age, in which increasing numbers of components and systems of an organism can be kept alive, and for longer intervals, the permanent cessation of functioning of the organism as a whole is the phenomenon that best corresponds to its death.

http://dx.doi.org/10.1002/hast.946

Voir la revue «The Hastings center report, 48»

Autres numéros de la revue «The Hastings center report»

Consulter en ligne

Suggestions

Du même auteur

Areas of consensus in withdrawing life-sustai...

Article indépendant | BERNAT, James L. | Neurology | vol.52

Editorial concernant les décisions d'arrêt des traitements destinés à maintenir en vie dans les unités neurologiques de soins intensifs, qui sont la cause de 40 à 65% des décès dans les unités de soins intensifs.

Areas of consensus in withdrawing life-sustai...

Article indépendant | BERNAT, James L. | Neurology | vol.52

Editorial concernant les décisions d'arrêt des traitements destinés à maintenir en vie dans les unités neurologiques de soins intensifs, qui sont la cause de 40 à 65% des décès dans les unités de soins intensifs.

A conceptual justification for brain death

Article indépendant | BERNAT, James L. | The Hastings center report | n°Suppl 4 | vol.48

Among the old and new controversies over brain death, none is more fundamental than whether brain death is equivalent to the biological phenomenon of human death. Here, I defend this equivalency by offering a brief conceptual just...

De la même série

"Please baptize my son" : the case against ba...

Article indépendant | SHEPHERD, Tate | The Hastings center report | n°1 | vol.55

A twenty-three-year-old atheist man was admitted to the intensive care unit after a motor vehicle accident left him terminally unconscious. He was not expected to survive long, so his religious mother asked the attending physician...

The case for baptizing a dying, unconscious a...

Article indépendant | BRUMMETT, Abram | The Hastings center report | n°1 | vol.55

In the essay "'Please baptize my son': The Case against Baptizing a Dying, Unconscious Atheist," in the same issue of this journal, Tate Shepherd and Michael Redinger describe a case in which a clinical ethicist is consulted when ...

Epistemic humility in the age of assisted dyi...

Article indépendant | RILEY, Sean | The Hastings center report | n°2 | vol.55

The current debate on medical assistance-in-dying (MAID) fails to acknowledge the limitations of empirical data and the influence that cognitive biases exert in interpreting evidence and formulating arguments. This paper examines ...

Opening the door : rethinking "difficult conv...

Article indépendant | BUCHBINDER, Mara | The Hastings center report | n°Suppl. 1 | vol.54

This essay looks closely at metaphors and other figures of speech that often feature in how Americans talk about dementia, becoming part of cultural narratives: shared stories that convey ideas and values, and also worries and fea...

Guiding the future : rethinking the role of a...

Article indépendant | GASTER, Barak | The Hastings center report | n°Suppl. 1 | vol.54

When people lose capacity to make a medical decision, the standard is to assess what their preferences would have been and try to honor their wishes. Dementia raises a special case in such situations, given its long, progressive t...

Chargement des enrichissements...