The morality of assisted dying

Article

RICHARDS, Stephen

This essay analyzes the morality of assisted dying. To do this, it is necessary to recognize that assisted dying is the outworking of a larger process. This process unavoidably begins with the key moral conception of human dignity. Emphasis upon individualism in society has caused a restructuring of the dignity concept, changing what is most highly valued. This altered concept of dignity gives rise to assisted dying, yet is morally flawed. This is because it is an understanding of dignity that minimizes people's vulnerability, dismisses coercive forces that are brought into effect, encourages undue confidence in safeguards, and removes any sustained basis for respect of the individual. Autonomy, as the primary justification for assisted dying in contemporary society, is an abbreviated understanding of the restructured concept of dignity and therefore subject to the same criticisms. Assisted dying arises from a deficient and self-defeating foundation that mark it as immoral.

http://dx.doi.org/10.1093/jmp/jhaf003

Voir la revue «The journal of medicine and philosophy»

Autres numéros de la revue «The journal of medicine and philosophy»

Consulter en ligne

Suggestions

Du même auteur

Exposing futility by searching beneath the co...

Article | RICHARDS, Stephen | Clinical ethics

The concept of futility in medicine refers to the incapability of an intervention to achieve its goal. Futility determinations form the basis for withholding and withdrawing life-sustaining interventions. Criticisms of attempted f...

Exposing futility by searching beneath the co...

Article indépendant | RICHARDS, Stephen | Clinical ethics

The concept of futility in medicine refers to the incapability of an intervention to achieve its goal. Futility determinations form the basis for withholding and withdrawing life-sustaining interventions. Criticisms of attempted f...

Exposing futility by searching beneath the co...

Article indépendant | RICHARDS, Stephen | Clinical ethics

The concept of futility in medicine refers to the incapability of an intervention to achieve its goal. Futility determinations form the basis for withholding and withdrawing life-sustaining interventions. Criticisms of attempted f...

De la même série

A dilemma for respecting autonomy : bridge te...

Article | KESTIGIAN, Aidan | The journal of medicine and philosophy | n°2 | vol.47

Respect for patient autonomy can apply at two levels: ensuring that patient care reflects their considered values and wishes and honoring patient preferences about how to make momentous decisions. Caregivers who seek to respect pa...

Reasoning about death in biomedical decision-...

Article | WEISSMAN, Jeremy | The journal of medicine and philosophy | n°3 | vol.47

Depending on our mode of reasoning-moral, prudential, instrumental, empirical, dialectical, and so on-we may come to vastly different conclusions on the nature of death and the appropriate orientation toward matters such as euthan...

Opioids, double effect, and the prospects of ...

Article | REED, Philip A. | The journal of medicine and philosophy

The relevance of double effect for end-of-life decision-making has been challenged recently by a number of scholars. The principal reason is that opioids such as morphine do not usually hasten death when administered to relieve pa...

Voluntarily stopping eating and drinking : co...

Article | MOSKOP, John C. | The journal of medicine and philosophy

Although voluntarily stopping eating and drinking (VSED) as a way to hasten one's death is not yet a widely recognized practice in the United States, it has received increasing attention in the medical and bioethics literature in ...

The role of hospice and palliative medicine i...

Article | DURHAM, Levi | The journal of medicine and philosophy

There is disagreement among physicians and medical ethicists on the precise goals of Hospice and Palliative Medicine (HPM). Some think that HPM's goals should differ from those of other branches of medicine and aim primarily at le...

Chargement des enrichissements...