TIEC, trauma capacity, and the moral priority of surrogate decision makers in futility disputes

Article indépendant

FIESTER, Autumn

In the past 15 years, trauma-informed care (TIC) has evolved as a new paradigm in healthcare that recognizes the impact of past traumas on patients' and families' healthcare experience while seeking to avoid inducing new trauma during clinical care. A recent paper by Lanphier and Anani extends TIC principles to healthcare ethics consultation (HEC) in what they label "trauma-informed ethics consultation" (TIEC), which calls for the "addition of trauma informed awareness, training, and skill in clinical ethics consultation." While Lanphier and Anani claim that TIEC is "novel, but not radical" because it builds on the approach to HEC endorsed by the American Society for Bioethics and Humanities, I believe that TIEC has radical implications, particularly regarding ethical obligations to surrogate decision makers (SDMs). Given what I call the SDM's "trauma capacity," I argue that TIEC accords moral priority to SDMs over patients in certain types of end-of-life cases, particularly futility disputes, which is a radical departure from the conventional HEC approach to SDMs.

http://dx.doi.org/10.1086/733392

Voir la revue «The journal of clinical ethics, 36»

Autres numéros de la revue «The journal of clinical ethics»

Consulter en ligne

Suggestions

Du même auteur

Surrogate wars : the "best interest values" h...

Article | FIESTER, Autumn | HEC forum

Conflicts involving end-of-life care between healthcare providers (HCPs) and surrogate decision-makers (SDMs) have received sustained attention for more than a quarter of a century, with early studies demonstrating a frequency of ...

Surrogate wars : the "best interest values" h...

Article indépendant | FIESTER, Autumn | HEC forum

Conflicts involving end-of-life care between healthcare providers (HCPs) and surrogate decision-makers (SDMs) have received sustained attention for more than a quarter of a century, with early studies demonstrating a frequency of ...

TIEC, trauma capacity, and the moral priority...

Article | FIESTER, Autumn | The journal of clinical ethics | n°1 | vol.36

In the past 15 years, trauma-informed care (TIC) has evolved as a new paradigm in healthcare that recognizes the impact of past traumas on patients' and families' healthcare experience while seeking to avoid inducing new trauma du...

De la même série

TIEC, trauma capacity, and the moral priority...

Article indépendant | FIESTER, Autumn | The journal of clinical ethics | n°1 | vol.36

In the past 15 years, trauma-informed care (TIC) has evolved as a new paradigm in healthcare that recognizes the impact of past traumas on patients' and families' healthcare experience while seeking to avoid inducing new trauma du...

Defining and refining trauma-informed ethics ...

Article indépendant | LANPHIER, Elizabeth | The journal of clinical ethics | n°1 | vol.36

This article responds to Autumn Fiester's "TIEC, Trauma Capacity, and the Moral Priority of Surrogate Decision Makers in Futility Disputes," in which Fiester argues for a vision of trauma-informed ethics consultation that systemat...

A deeper look at ethics consultation

Article indépendant | MORREIM, Haavi | The journal of clinical ethics | n°1 | vol.36

Autumn Fiester suggests that trauma-informed ethics consultation (TIEC) should focus on surrogate decision makers (SDMs) in preference over patients when (a) the patient is comatose or neurologically devastated, and hence beyond t...

DNAR order status changes during surgical pro...

Article indépendant | JOHNSON, Lily | The journal of clinical ethics | n°2 | vol.36

AbstractIntroduction: The practice of automatic suspension of "do not attempt resuscitation" (DNAR) orders has been abandoned in favor of more nuanced discussions. We sought to assess the practical implementation of DNAR orders at...

Patient perspectives on the authority of adva...

Article indépendant | POTTER, Jordan | The journal of clinical ethics | n°2 | vol.36

AbstractContext: As advance directives (ADs) become more frequently utilized, opportunities increase for conflict between a patient's designated healthcare power of attorney (POA) and the treatment preferences outlined in their li...

Chargement des enrichissements...